| Year | Champion | Reserve Champion | Location |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1982 | Vergil Holland & Sugar | Edgar Gould & Roy | TopsField |
| 1983 | Vergil Holland & Robin | Walt Jagger & Floss | TopsField |
| 1984 | Vergil Holland & Sugar | Vergil Holland & Robin | Pepperell,MA |
| 1985 | Vergil Holland & Sugar | Walt Jagger & Dot | Canaday Farm,NY |
| 1986 | Mike Canaday & Sandy | Walt Jagger & Dot | Canaday Farm,NY |
| 1987 | Lynn Deschambeault & Dandy | Vergil Holland & Robin | Canaday Farm,NY |
| 1988 | Roger Deschambeault & Sue | Cheryl Jagger & Nell | Strafford,VT |
| 1989 | Walt Jagger & Tweed | Beverly Lambert & Jet | Bangor,ME |
| 1990 | Cheryl Jagger Williams & Nell | Beverly Lambert & Jet | Canaday Farm,NY |
| 1991 | Cheryl Jagger Williams & Kim | Amanda Milliken & Hazel | Holland Farm,NY |
| 1992 | Mike Canaday & Jill | Eve Marschark & Spin | Strafford,VT |
| 1993 | Cheryl Jagger Williams & Kim | Beverly Lambert & Jet | Carlisle,PA |
| 1994 | Eve Marschark & Spin | Barbara Armata & Kelly | Lamprey River Farm,NH |
| 1995 | Mike Canaday & Ken | Beverly Lambert & Lark | Fosterfields,NJ |
| 1996 | Walt Jagger & Roy | Mike Canaday & Robin | Hampshire College,MA |
| 1997 | Beverly Lambert & Lark | Mike Canaday & Robin | Old Chatham,NY |
| 1998 | Mike Canaday & Ben | Amanda Milliken & Hazel | Old Chatham,NY |
| 1999 | Lorna Savage & Dot | Warren Mick & Tim | Old Chatham,NY |
| 2000 | Beverly Lambert & Pippa | Cheryl Jagger Williams & Ben | Old Chatham,NY |
| 2001 | Beverly Lambert & Pippa | Amanda Milliken & Eucher | Sydenham,ON |
| 2002 | Amanda Milliken & Eucher | Amanda Milliken & Grace | Cooperstown,NY |
| 2003 | Warren Mick & Glen | Beverly Lambert & Bill | Turbotville,PA |
| 2004 | Beverly Lambert & Bill | Beverly Lambert & Pippa | Amherst,MA |
| 2005 | Beverly Lambert & Bill | Lori Cunningham & Tess | Amherst,MA |
| 2006 | Lorna Savage & Zoe | Gene Sheninger & Jen | Mendon,NY |
| 2007 | No Fall Foliage Held | No Fall Foliage Held | No Fall Foliage Held |
| 2008 | Cheryl Jagger-Williams & Spot | Nancy Ortiz-Sharp & Aldebaran | Cooperstown,NY |
| 2009 | Amanda Milliken & Ethel | Amanda Milliken & Clive | Westfield,VT |
| 2010 | No Fall Foliage Held | No Fall Foliage Held | No Fall Foliage Held |
| 2011 | Warren Mick & Dale | Maria Mick & Bodie | Cooperstown,NY |
| 2012 | Sue Schoen & Esther | Mich Ferraro & Clive | Pine City ,NY |
| 2013 | Warren Mick & Shep | Bev Lambert & Nan | Bath,NH |
| 2014 | Bev Lambert & Joe | Bev Lambert & Nan | Harford ,PA |
| 2015 | Warren Mick & Eddie | Amanda Milliken & Howell | Old Chatham,NY |
| 2016 | Amanda Milliken & Howell | Bev Lambert & Joe | Old Chatham,NY |
| 2017 | Mich Ferraro & Puppa | Dave Young & Pic | Cooperstown,NY |
| 2018 | Bev Lambert & Nan | Amanda Milliken & Howell | Millerton,NY |
| 2019 | Warren Mick & Eddie | Mich Ferraro & Mawde | Millerton,NY |
| 2020 | No Fall Foliage Held | No Fall Foliage Held | No Fall Foliage Held |
| 2021 | No Fall Foliage Held | No Fall Foliage Held | No Fall Foliage Held |
| 2022 | Val Henry & Tag | Paul Batz & Reyn | Canandaigua,NY |
| 2023 | Paul Batz & Reyn | John Palmer & Mara | Canandaigua,NY |